Nicky`s Carryout in Crestwood

Nicky`s Carryout in Crestwood
4.5 / 5
50 reviews

14001 Cicero Ave, Crestwood, IL 60445-2150, Crestwood

Overview

Cuisine
  • Fast Food

Restaurant Hours

Monday

08:00 - 17:00

Tuesday

08:00 - 17:00

Wednesday

08:00 - 17:00

Thursday

00:00 - 17:00

Friday

00:00 - 17:00

How is the food

Delicious. The gyros are superb, we love the Chicago dogs, get your fries crispy! Everything I've had has always been delicious and a great price. But my favorites are the Chicago dogs and gyros.

Why is the food so good and priced just right !!

To me it's always about their gyros plates. I haven't found a place where they are generous with the amount they give at the price they charge. Granted it wasn't always $10, but you still get great value and the quality is great. I been going here since i was in my teens. I still travel to go back and it's still good.

Do you accept credit cards? I thought I saw a credit card machine last time I was there.

Yes! We happy to announce we proudly accept all major credit and debit cards

Great hotdogs and fries. ..

Good prices also. The Big Baby Burger is good too.

Review

Add rating restaurant:
Nicky`s Carryout
MK
Mike Kruczek
google
11.20.2024
5/5

Amazing authentic food, just what your taste buds need! I recommend this place for their service and delicious food. You WONT be disappointed, I recommend their Big Baby Burgers.

Nicky`s Carryout
ls
lois shive
google
10.14.2018
5/5

Have gone to Nicky's for years, good Gyros and Beefs.They allowed my daughter to sit there for several hours waiting to be picked up on Halloween. Thank you for having a safe, warm place for our kids!

Nicky`s Carryout
LK
Lucy Klotz
google
10.04.2018
3/5

Love the food but the old lady at the register is always cranky. Never friendly no matter how hard I try to make her smile.

Nicky`s Carryout
DG
Daniel Gruwell
google
09.26.2018
5/5

This place is the best. Great food, large portions. Definitely will be going back. Well worth the money.

Nicky`s Carryout
TS
Thomas Sanocki
google
07.20.2018
4/5

Great prices on good food. The exception is too hot inside there in warm weather and too damn cold in there in winter...

Nicky`s Carryout
Alisia
google
06.11.2018
5/5

Good food and they take debit/credit cards now

Nicky`s Carryout
PT
Patricia Tomachevsky
google
06.04.2018
5/5

The food here is amazing. I personally prefer a gyro plate, fries or a burger from here! You will not be disappointed!

Nicky`s Carryout
JT
John Tsikouris
google
05.22.2018
5/5

Best Gyros in the land! Huge portions too!

Nicky`s Carryout
YM
Yvette McKinney
google
05.10.2018
1/5

It's unbelievable that mask requirement isn't posted on the door. Because of this, there were customers who weren't wearing masks. Even more disturbing, the staff weren't wearing masks. Nicky's blatant disregard of the state's face covering mandate is foolish. It's people and businesses like Nicky's that perpetuate the virus. .Nobody is thrilled about wearing masks, we all want to live...it beats wearing a ventilator.

Nicky`s Carryout
lg
luke gabrel
google
04.05.2018
5/5

Been going here for years. I had almost everything on the menu. Never left disappointed or hungry. We ordered carry out today got a bag full of big baby double cheeseburgers, hot dogs and fries. The bill ended up under $20. Dinner for the whole family.

Nicky`s Carryout
AT
Angel Thomas
google
02.19.2018
5/5

The food was Great! From pizza puff, gyro, maxwell polish, shrimp & fries! Hot & fresh!

Nicky`s Carryout
AR
Annette Roberson
google
02.14.2018
4/5

I think too many people inside. I order and stand outside. Food is usually great

Nicky`s Carryout
HB
Highly Blessed
google
11.14.2017
1/5

Not to my liking my stomach did not enjoy it. I had the gyro

Nicky`s Carryout
KW
Kisha W
google
11.10.2017
5/5

Love their Italian beef, dipped with hot peppers. Lots of meat, sliced thin and very flavorful. You also can get a good sized crispy skin on french fries. I just wished they had it as a combo meal.

Nicky`s Carryout
JC
Jeff Conrad
google
11.05.2017
5/5

I've been going to Nicky's for 20 years great place to eat with friendly employees and good deals.

Nicky`s Carryout
AM
AJ Matariyeh
google
10.22.2017
5/5

The have literally the best gyros I've ever tried. Been going by them for years and still they are the best!! They work super fast fo get your food done so you are in and out quick. Thank God you guys are here.

Nicky`s Carryout
MM
Margaret Miranda
google
10.17.2017
5/5

You know this is one of those places that have been there for ever. Kinda good tasting good old American faire - Hotdogs, Polish, Hamburgers etc much more . Which means their patrons love it! Including me.

Nicky`s Carryout
SC
Sam Castillo
google
09.10.2017
5/5

If you have a chance stop in. Got the gyro plate for myself and I could have ded my family. 3 hour dog special made my son happy and double cheeseburger mmt daughter said was flavorful and filling. A must place to visit if you're in the area. We will be back!

Nicky`s Carryout
AC
Ash Conley
google
09.01.2017
5/5

Ridiculously huge gyro plate! Good hot dog, GREAT fries

Nicky`s Carryout
md
mercedes debella
google
08.08.2017
3/5

Overly priced. They are pricing themselves out of the market. Many other places offer more for less price and better quality of food.

Nicky`s Carryout
KK
Kevin K
google
07.21.2017
5/5

Just like everyone else I’ve eaten here since I was a little kid, I’ve lived down the street for YEARS and it’s my absolute favorite spot for gyros - if you get a platter they can barely close it - AMAZING - so flavorful and so good! I come here every time I’m back in town now. Weird parking, gets crowded at times, and this place is cash only so come prepared. All in all a great Chicago staple in the great food belt

Nicky`s Carryout
DB
Davonda Buck
google
07.14.2017
4/5

The gyro platter was plentiful and delicious.

Nicky`s Carryout
MV
Mercedes Vega
google
06.02.2017
5/5

Best Italian beefs & gyros I ever had. The amount of meat they put on these bad boys are insane enough for two people. I moved to the north side of Chicago and still drive miles just to have their food 😩💞👌🏻

Nicky`s Carryout
AC
Amber Campbell
google
05.21.2017
1/5

Zero stars. You guys are honestly disgusting!!! Wearing no masks! Most of the cooks have no gloves, the ones that did they were torn at the fingertips. I had to leave as I was placing an order all I could see is them touching food with no gloves. Honestly this place should be shut down!

Nicky`s Carryout
AL
Andy Linss
google
05.16.2017
5/5

I've been here a couple of times. Their fries are super good and I liked a gyro sandwich as well. My last visit was 3 hot dogs with everything and I think they were the best I ever had.

Nicky`s Carryout
CG
Charles Green
google
04.19.2017
5/5

Always a great place to get some good fast food, BIG BABY

Nicky`s Carryout
AF
Angela Flores
google
04.11.2017
5/5

The best place to get 5 beef hot dogs & a decent size fry for.$5.55 served with a smile & friendly staff =).

Nicky`s Carryout
JC
John Carter
google
03.17.2017
5/5

love this place awesome food great price old school burger hotdog joint i love it cant find these anymore in the city

Nicky`s Carryout
AK
Angela Koepp
google
02.14.2017
5/5

Always the best best best experience. We moved out of state 4 years ago but we ALWAYS make it back to Nicky's. The lady who handles the customers (and I'm sure a whole lot more) feels like a part of my childhood. ❤ Look at this freaking gyro platter!! 🤯🤤

Nicky`s Carryout
LL
Lee Lee Wright
google
02.09.2017
2/5

I love this place and wanted to give it a five star rating. However, due to the pandemic and Illinois mask mandate I have to give it less stars. I have been here multiple times and NONE of the workers wear mask. They also don’t reinforce the mask mandate. As a teacher and health care provider it would be risky for me to continue to come here. I implore that the management enforce the mask mandate to their workers before the state finds out and close them down. The food is good but you need to follow the rules.

Nicky`s Carryout
DR
Daniel Redden
google
01.10.2017
5/5

It's very good food at a fair price and do now accept credit and debit cards and the staff is very friendly I was there today

Nicky`s Carryout
MN
Melissa Nobles
google
01.09.2017
4/5

I love their 3 hot dogs plus fries for $ 6.00 and some change which is not bad for beef hot dogs.

Nicky`s Carryout
AM
Aaron Mitchell
google
01.03.2017
5/5

Really great food, awesome prices, good people. I just wish they accepted debit/credit cards. That would put them over the top!

Nicky`s Carryout
RR
Robert Reyes
google
01.01.2017
5/5

Great prices and great service. I've been here on multiple occasions and have NEVER been disappointed. The gyros are also fantastic!

Nicky`s Carryout
CR
Carlos Rivera
google
11.20.2016
5/5

Best Chicago style everything you can ever find...

Nicky`s Carryout
AK
Amy K
google
11.13.2016
5/5

Love grabbing a quick bite here! Their fries are really good!

Nicky`s Carryout
DA
Darvel A. Stinson
google
10.08.2016
5/5

Great food, best in town. No matter what you order, you wont be disappointed!

Nicky`s Carryout
ES
Ed S
google
09.19.2016
1/5

Their service and business fell off years ago. Ever wonder why they cover up their cash register with a plastic trash bag. It's so that it doesn't malfunction or become damaged when they spray the bug spray every evening when they close. You know they have an insect problem when they do that. Don't believe me? Then drive by during the early morning hours before they open and you'll see that bag over their register.

Nicky`s Carryout
JP
Jim Poynton
google
09.13.2016
5/5

Look, simply put, if you want the best gyros platter on the planet, go to Nicky's. I used to live in the area and ate there all the time. Now I'm 20 minutes away, but it's worth the trip. We buy two platters, two extra pitas, and it feeds my family of six with some meat left over. The best!

Nicky`s Carryout
JL
Jim Lestinsky
google
08.24.2016
4/5

Been eating here since I was a wee munchkin. 34 yrs old now and this place is still as good as it was when I was 10. If your looking for healthy food, go someplace else. Only reason I dont give 5 stars is because of the CASH ONLY policy. Its 2019, come on...... other than that, A++ rating for the tasty food.

Nicky`s Carryout
BI
Bill Ibarra
google
08.24.2016
4/5

Great food!! Comes out hot, fresh, and fast! Lots of parking. Staff was friendly, and no errors were made in our order. Small dining room, but great for take out.

Nicky`s Carryout
TP
Timothy Piatkiewicz
google
08.20.2016
5/5

Good food, good prices, fast service and now they take credit cards.

Nicky`s Carryout
RC
Richard Conner
google
07.05.2016
4/5

Banging as usual. Heavy portions. Make sure you grab extra pitas. The best.

Nicky`s Carryout
CA
Carrie Andrzejewski
google
05.21.2016
5/5

Their gyro sandwich is great. Buy an extra pita and sauce and there's enough meat on one sandwich to make two. Great greasy fries.

Nicky`s Carryout
SB
Sweet Brute
google
05.19.2016
5/5

Good price good hot food

Nicky`s Carryout
JN
James Nardin
google
05.08.2016
5/5

Love this place good food and they're fast and friendly.

Nicky`s Carryout
KS
Katrice Sullivan
google
04.14.2016
2/5

I liked the taste of Italian Beef at Baby's, in Country Club Hills better.

Nicky`s Carryout
AC
April Clarke
google
03.19.2016
3/5

Went to Nicky's today (5/14/20) the food was amazing, as I expected it would be! I'm sorry to report that, not one person working there was wearing a protective mask or gloves. I was very disheartened by this! I don't think I feel safe returning there until they are willing to show they care about the safety of themselves and their customers

Nicky`s Carryout
SL
Skorpyun's Lair
google
02.19.2016
5/5

My grandmother would bring me here as a child and I still come here when I'm in state. The gyros have always been flavored the same. Great tzaziki sauce. Always had an honest price and a clean restaurant. Been here for 35 years that I know of. I recommend it.

Nicky`s Carryout
AK
Andrew KPro
google
01.17.2016
5/5

Delicious burgers and best tasting fresh cut fries.

Your question has been sent.

Expect an answer!

Thank!

Your review has been submitted.

Order food

Reservation

Want to order over the phone?

Call 17083884626

Thank you for being with us!

We will call you back!